Choosing the Best Gutter Guards: A Buying Guide for 2022

Selecting the best gutter guards is a decision that will pay off for years to come. Gutters are an integral part of our home’s roof as they play a role in maintaining both its structural integrity and longevity.

 Best Gutter GuardView in gallery

Whenever it rains, gutters collect water and help to direct it away from the home. Therefore, installing gutter guards will help keep any debris and leaves from clogging up your rain gutters or downspouts. 

Best Gutter Guards of 2022

If you’re new to purchasing gutter guards and aren’t sure where to start, we’ve got you covered. We have rounded up ten of the best gutter guards with detailed reviews to get you started. We review several different types of gutter guards: micro mesh gutter guards, foam gutter guards, brush gutter guards, reverse curve gutter guards, and screen gutter guards.

Leaf Filter Gutter Guards: Best System Overall

GutterStuff GS K5 Foam Gutter Guards 1024x683View in gallery

This gutter guard is a three piece system containing a stainless steel micro mesh, uPVC frame, and structural hangers that fit onto your facia board. Micro mesh gutter guards keep out debris because of the thin stainless steel mesh that covers the gutters.

The Leaf Filter mesh is 275 microns fine which keeps out even small debris. This particular design has a unique angled construction that doesn’t allow debris buildup and creates better water flow. In addition, this gutter system comes with professional installation and has a lifetime guarantee that is transferable when you sell your home.

Pros

  • Estimates are free and last for one year.
  • This system is effective and eliminates debris in gutters.
  • This system is made from durable materials.
  • The Leaf Filter system works with all types of gutters.

Cons

  • This is one of the more expensive gutter guard options.
  • These are not DIY gutter guards; you must use professional installation.

GutterStuff GS-K5 Foam Gutter Guards: Best Invisible Guard

GutterStuff GS K5 Foam Gutter Guards 1024x683View in gallery

The GutterStuff guards are a foam insert that you push down inside your gutters. This foam guard keeps debris out but allows the water to flow through. This foam is made from a polyether outdoor foam that is protected with a UV and germicide treatment. In addition, each foam section is 4 feet long and comes in widths of 4 and 5 inches; these sizes work in most standard gutters.

Pros

  • This is a DIY gutter guard as you can install them yourself.
  • These gutter guards have a three year guarantee.
  • This is an inexpensive option.
  • These gutter guards cannot be seen from the ground level as they fit inside the gutters.

Cons

  • Leaves build up on the top of this gutter system.
  • May not prevent the breeding of mosquitoes.

All-American Gutter Protection: Best for Customization

This is another micro mesh gutter guard system with a solid reputation for good performance and customer service. This gutter system has a stainless steel micro mesh that fits into an aluminum frame.

However, this system also needs to have professional installation because of its more complex design. These come in 30 different colors, so you can customize it to blend with the color of your trim. These also have a lifetime guarantee, and they promise that nothing other than water will get through their fine micro mesh.
Pros

  • 30 color options are available.
  • This company is known for good customer service.
  • This system has a solid reputation for performance and reliability.

Cons

  • This system is not available in the whole country. At this time they are available in 15 states.
  • Micro mesh gutter guards are some of the most expensive options for gutter guards.

Amerimax Reverse Curve Gutter Guards: Best Price

Amerimax gutter guards are a product that features a solid panel known as surface tension gutter guards or reverse curve gutter guards. You snap these solid panels on top of your existing gutters. Amerimax has constructed this panel from durable PVC which comes in various sizes to fit standard gutters.

This is among many choices of Home Depot gutter guards and is available in the stores for purchase. In addition, this is a DIY gutter guard option and is the best price available.
Pros

  • These gutter guards are inexpensive.
  • The panels are easy to install and replace if you have problems with them.

Cons

  • This gutter guard does not perform as well compared to more expensive gutter guards.
  • These gutter guards warp and crack easier than more durable options made from steel.

Gutterglove Micro-mesh Gutter Guard: Best DIY Micro Mesh

Gutterglove screen gutter guard is an option that you can install yourself. However, this is not a full system, but rather panels that you can put over your existing gutters.

These micro mesh panels come in sections that are 4 feet long and 5 1/2 inches wide and in packs of 10 per order. You secure each panel using the included screws.

Also, once you have ordered the product and registered with Gutterglove, you will receive a 25 year guarantee for your gutter guards.
Pros

  • This is an efficient and durable system.
  • It is cost-effective for micro-mesh gutter guards.
  • These are DIY gutter guards for those who want to do their own gutter guard installation.

Cons

  • Heavy rain can roll off the guards.
  • This is not a good option if you want your gutter guards installed.

Gutterbrush Gutter Guard: Best Brush Guards

This is a version of gutter guards featuring a wire brush made with a steel core covered in polypropylene. This brush fits into the gutter to keep out debris while still allowing water to run through.

The Gutterbrush gutter guard comes in five different sizes and is able to fit most standard gutters. Each width comes in a 60 foot pack. Also, these are easy to install as there is no cutting and screwing to fit. Just slide each brush end to end in your gutters.
Pros

  • This gutter guard is easy to install.
  • The brush comes in multiple sizes so it fits in most gutters.
  • This system is well-loved by homeowners and professionals for working well.

Cons

  • These guards do not keep all small debris out of the gutters.
  • These will need to be replaced after several years as they are not as durable as other options.

Homecraft Gutter Protection: Best Designed System

This is an all-inclusive micro mesh system designed by Homecraft. The micro mesh cover is crafted from marine grade stainless steel. In addition, it has a raised diamond pattern embossed onto the mesh to lift large debris buildup while still allowing water to flow through. Also, these mesh covers are not held in place with a substructure; rather, they are mounted on a powder coated steel frame that they install on the sides of the gutters.
Pros

  • This is a durable and long-lasting system.
  • This system has a comprehensive warranty that is transferable to new owners.
  • The installers will repair the existing gutter system before installing their screen gutter guards.

Cons

  • This gutter system is available in just 10 states.
  • There is no DIY installation.
  • These are one of the more expensive gutter guard options.

Amerimax Hoover Dam: Best Screen

These gutter guards from Amerimax feature large mesh panels that you can order and install yourself. They are constructed from a powder coated steel for longevity and durability.

Also, these panels come in 3 feet long and 7 inch wide panels, so they fit over most standard gutters. In addition, they have a unique ridged design that keeps debris from getting stuck and water flowing. These gutters have a 15 year warranty and are perfect to keep large debris like leaves out.

Pros

  • The ridged design allows water to run off well.
  • These covers are easy to install.

Cons

  • These are expensive compared to other cover options.
  • The mesh is larger so small debris can fall through.

A-M Gutter Guards: Best Durability

The A-M Gutter Guard is known for its high quality and durable construction. It features heavy gauge aluminum panels that you fit into the gutter hanger. Therefore, it is adaptable to any roof design. In addition, it comes in 4 foot panels with 380 holes per linear foot with a ridged design to allow better water flow. Thus, these are designed to handle heavy rain with ease. Also, it is one of the most excellent leaf gutter guards but not as good at keeping other debris out.
Pros

  • This company constructs their panels for durability and heavy use.
  • You can use these with any type of roof design.
  • These are hidden from the ground.

Cons

  • These panels do not come with installation screws.
  • The ridged design can collect debris.

Amerimax Snap-In Guards: Best Value

Amerimax crafts their snap-in panels with a large grid pattern. They make these panels from PVC to snap onto most K-style gutters. Also, these gutters are easy to install; you must slide one edge under the roof singles on one side and snap to the front of the gutters on the other side. In addition, there is a bonded filter mesh that traps small debris and the grids allow the water to run through.
Pros

  • These are one of the least expensive options for gutter guards.
  • The Amerimax gutter guards are easy to install.
  • These fit most K-style gutters.

Cons

  • These are not as long lasting as PVC can sag over time.

Things to Consider When Buying Gutter Guards

Purchasing gutter guards can be an expensive proposition, so it is important to choose the right option for your needs and budget.

Materials

  • Stainless steel – The stainless steel material is one of the most long-lasting and is able to withstand heavy usage. However, this is one of the most expensive materials that manufacturers use in guards.
  • PVC – PVC is a very inexpensive material that used to be the most popular material used for gutter guards. However, this material does not wear as well over time.
  • Aluminum – Some metal gutter guards use aluminum rather than steel because it is lighter and more pliable. Of course, this material is less expensive than steel.
  • Foam – Gutter guard companies treat foam inserts to preserve them against bugs and the sun. However, these do deteriorate over time.

Longevity

Gutter guards made from stainless steel are longer lasting than those made with plastic. Also, check the warranties before you purchase gutter guards. In addition, some guard systems have lifetime warranties and others just have them for a few years.

Design

Consider the style of your house and the style of different types of gutter guards. Some guards have an overt style and others are more minimal. Also, consider the color of your gutters and trim. Some gutters have customizable color choices and others come in just a few colors.

Installation

Each gutter guard has a different installation process. For example, some of the top gutter guards are an entire gutter system that requires professional installation. However, some gutter guards are a gutter cover for the gutter beneath. Of course, these are easier for the amatuer to install.

Price

There is a direct line between the price and the durability of the gutter guards. Of course, the full gutter systems are more expensive than just gutter covers. Therefore, gutter guards made from stainless steel are more expensive than those made from plastic. However, not everyone can afford the most expensive options and even if they can, they are not for everyone. Thus, it depends on how much you need to clean your gutters and how long you are planning on being in your house.

Gutter Guard Cost

These prices include the cost of materials per linear foot and installation.

  • PVC gutter guard – $.40-$1.00 per linear foot and $50-$200 for installation.
  • Foam gutter guard – $2.00-$3.25 per linear foot and $300-$700 for installation.
  • Micro-mesh gutter guard – $2.00-$4.00 per linear foot and $900-$2,000 for installation.
  • Brush gutter guard – $3.00-$4.25 per linear foot and $600-$900 for installation.
  • Steel screen gutter guards – $1.50-$3.50 per linear foot and $800-$1500 for installation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)FAQ

Do gutter guards work?

The short answer is yes, most gutter guards work. However, they are not the answer to never having to clean the gutter again. Instead, gutter guards seem to minimize the amount of time that you will spend cleaning out the gutter, and they minimize the amount of debris that collects in your gutters. In order to be the most effective, it is important to install gutter guards in the right way as well as maintain them over time. Check them on a regular basis to head off any large problems that may arise.

Do gutter guards cause problems?

Gutter guards can cause some problems if you do not install them well. This includes the buildup of water around the gutters causing problems to the room and facia boards. Also, water can build up in the winter causing ice dams which will result in water damage if not addressed.

Should I remove gutter guards in winter?

Make sure to clean gutters and check to make sure the guards are installed well before each winter. If you do these things, there is no need to remove the gutter guards all year.

What are the disadvantages of gutter guards?

Gutter guards have obvious advantages including less frequent gutter cleaning. However, there are also some disadvantages including the expense, the possibility that gutter guards can cause more rain to fall over the gutter leading to more water near your foundation, and that gutter guards make it more difficult to clean out any debris that does end up in your gutters.

Do gutter guards add value to your home?

Well maintained gutter guards are an attractive prospect to potential homebuyers, but they do not add monetary value to your home.

Gutter Guards: Conclusion

Choosing and installing gutter guards doesn’t have to be a complicated process, and we hope that this guide has helped you make your decision. However, it is vital that you figure out what type of gutter guard will work with the gutters you have.

Thus, it pays to spend a little more on a product that’s durable and made of high-quality material. In the end, the right purchase will not just help extend the life of your gutters, it will keep debris out and save you valuable time.

With a proper gutter guard, you’re on your way to a rust-free, clog-free, and pest-free gutter.