His new neighbor wanted his oak tree cut down because leaves fell in her pool: then she said she was a lawyer
  1. Homedit
  2. How To, Tips, and Advice

His new neighbor wanted his oak tree cut down because leaves fell in her pool: then she said she was a lawyer

A Texas homeowner had lived in his house for more than 20 years, with a mature oak tree providing shade across his backyard and part of the property next door. Four different neighbors had lived beside him during that time, and none had asked him to remove the tree, despite its leaves falling across the fence.

That changed when a new owner bought the neighboring house. She wanted the oak removed because leaves were falling into her swimming pool. After the homeowner and his wife declined, she came to their door, mentioned that she was a lawyer, and warned that she didn’t want the disagreement to become messy.

His new neighbor wanted his oak tree cut down because leaves fell in her pool then she said she was a lawyer

The New Neighbor Wanted the Oak Tree Removed Because of Her Pool

In a Reddit post on r/neighborsfromhell, user u/Fancy_Season372 explained that the new owner had purchased the neighboring property about a month earlier.

The tree stood inside his backyard, but several branches extended across the fence. He acknowledged that fallen leaves created extra work for the neighbors, although the four previous owners had considered the summer shade worth the inconvenience.

The new owner contacted his wife after obtaining her phone number through her real estate agent. She asked whether the couple would consider removing the oak tree.

His wife declined because they had removed other trees and made landscaping changes. Their arborist had advised against making further changes until the yard had time to recover.

The neighbor then visited the couple’s house to discuss the tree in person.

She Said She Was a Lawyer and Wanted Two More Trees Removed

The homeowner told the neighbor that he would need advice from his arborist before considering work on the oak. According to his account, she responded by bringing up her profession.

“She mentioned she’s a lawyer and doesn’t want this to ‘get messy’.”

The request also extended beyond the oak tree. The neighbor wanted two more trees removed from the homeowner’s property, even though neither stood near her house. She offered to have other trees she considered unattractive trimmed during the same work.

She wanted to use her own tree contractor rather than the arborist the homeowner had hired for years.

The homeowner said the new owner had moved from California and planned to rent out the house rather than live there. Her plans left him concerned about the trees and whether pruning the oak’s overhanging branches could cause damage.

The Texas State Law Library explains that a neighboring property owner can trim branches extending across the property line but could face a lawsuit if the work injures the tree. The right to trim branches does not give a neighbor permission to enter the owner’s yard or remove the entire tree.

Tree health also matters when deciding how much to cut. The Texas A&M Forest Service warns that removing large portions of mature trees can cause stress and that oak pruning carries a risk of spreading oak wilt, particularly from February through June.

She Said She Was a Lawyer and Wanted Two More Trees Removed

Reddit Commenters Urged the Homeowner to Document the Tree

The post attracted more than 1,700 votes and over 1,000 comments, with readers questioning the neighbor’s requests and her reference to being a lawyer.

Reddit user u/little-raven3 suggested documenting the tree before any work took place:

“Take photos of the whole tree and property now.”

Other commenters recommended obtaining a written assessment from the homeowner’s arborist, checking local tree ordinances, and keeping records of conversations with the new owner.

Some readers raised another concern: the new owner had asked for two additional trees to be removed even though they did not extend onto her property.

The homeowner had not reported removing or pruning the oak tree, and no court action or further resolution was confirmed in the thread.

Tree removal has led to other disputes between neighbors. In another case reported by Homedit, a family cut down a tree because birds left droppings on their cars, then began parking beneath their neighbor’s tree when summer arrived.

In a separate dispute, a homeowner refused to contribute $4,000 toward removing two spruce trees, but the disagreement returned when he needed access through the adjoining yard to sell his property.

Would you allow a new neighbor to remove a mature oak tree because its leaves were falling into their swimming pool?


Story credit: Reddit user u/Fancy_Season372, who shared the dispute in r/neighborsfromhell.