His neighbors cut down their shade tree: when summer arrived, they started parking under his
For more than 25 years, a large tree provided shade for cars parked along a suburban street. When new neighbors moved in, they cut it down because birds nesting in its branches were leaving droppings on their vehicles. Months later, summer temperatures rose, and the family began parking beneath the remaining tree outside the house next door.
The homeowner next door had no driveway or garage, while the neighbors had both. After two weeks of returning home to find the shaded parking space occupied, he taped a note to the tree telling them to plant their own. Days later, the neighbors left a reply, arguing that anyone could park on the public street.
The Neighbors Removed a Tree That Had Stood for 25 Years
In a Reddit post on r/AITAH, user u/Glenncoco23 explained that the previous owner of the neighboring house had lived there for about 40 years. Before moving, she expressed concern that the incoming owners might remove the tree, which had survived storms and hurricanes.
The new residents were a family of six with four cars. They removed the tree near the end of fall, when falling temperatures made the loss of shade less noticeable.
Summer Parking Led to a Dispute Over the Remaining Tree
By late June, the family had begun using the parking space beneath the tree outside the Reddit author’s home, despite having curb space outside their own property.
The homeowner worked in construction and spent long days exposed to the sun. Returning from work to find the space occupied meant leaving his car in the heat.
After two weeks, he taped an unsigned note to the trunk:
“If you want shade, plant a tree.”
A few days later, another message appeared:
“This is a public street. We can park where we want.”
The homeowner acknowledged that the street was public. His objection was that the family had removed one shade tree and was now using another.
Reddit Commenters Questioned the Tree Removal and the Notes
Several commenters questioned whether the neighbors had permission to remove the original tree. Both trees stood in the strip between the sidewalk and street, where municipal tree regulations may apply.
Removing a tree from the strip between a sidewalk and the street can have legal consequences, even when the tree stands outside someone’s home. In Portland, Oregon, city regulations require a permit before removing a street tree. Under the city’s tree enforcement code, unauthorized removal can result in civil penalties of up to $1,000 per day, with each tree treated as a separate violation.
The financial consequences can extend beyond the initial penalty. Portland’s 2026 tree enforcement fee schedule lists a restoration fee of $472 per inch of trunk diameter for a removed tree. The Reddit author did not identify his city or state, and there is no evidence that his neighbors violated local regulations. Whether a permit was required, or any penalty could apply, depends on the tree’s location and the laws governing it.
One Reddit commenter shared a similar experience involving a tree in the strip between the sidewalk and street. User u/mcnonnie25 wrote:
“Interesting. We got sued by the city because my husband cut down the tree in the curb strip in front of our house.”
The commenter explained that the family was responsible for maintaining the strip but did not own the land. In this case, the Reddit author never confirmed whether his neighbors obtained permission to remove the tree.
Tree removal has caused other neighborhood disputes. In another case reported by Homedit, a landlord refused to contribute $4,000 toward removing two spruce trees, then paid that amount when he needed access through the neighbor’s yard to sell his house.
Other Reddit commenters criticized the homeowner’s approach. User u/ajulesd suggested speaking to the family before leaving a note. The homeowner agreed:
“Admittedly, you’re right. I really should’ve done that.”
He explained that his long construction shifts had left him frustrated after two weeks of finding the parking space occupied.
Other commenters argued that the neighbors had the right to park on a public street, even if their decision seemed inconsiderate. Reddit user u/cgrobin1 summarized the difference between parking rights and neighborhood courtesy:
“What they are doing is rude, but not illegal.”
The commenter noted that homeowners often expect to use the space outside their own house, but that expectation does not give them exclusive rights to public parking.
No further resolution was reported.
Parking and property boundaries have caused other disputes between neighbors. In one case, homeowners were asked to pay for a fence built before they moved in, but the neighbors refused to show them the bill. Another homeowner ordered a property survey after his neighbor claimed two feet of land beyond a fence, only to discover the fence stood on their property. In a separate dispute, neighbors kept parking in a homeowner’s driveway and later cut through his fence to access his pool.
Would you have left the note, or spoken to the neighbors about the parking space?
Story credit: Reddit user u/Glenncoco23, who shared the experience in r/AITAH.


