His neighbor claimed two feet beyond his fence: when he ordered his own survey, he discovered the fence was on their land
  1. Homedit
  2. How To, Tips, and Advice

His neighbor claimed two feet beyond his fence: when he ordered his own survey, he discovered the fence was on their land

A couple had lived in their home for 15 years when they decided to install a backyard fence. They hired surveyors to mark the property boundaries, but one of the stakes landed beyond a neighbor’s chain-link fence. The neighbor insisted he owned another two feet of land past his fence and threatened to call his lawyer and the sheriff.

The couple’s surveyors checked their measurements and returned to mark the boundary. The neighbor refused to accept their findings and arranged another survey. But the result went against him: his fence stood two feet inside the couple’s property, and he told them he would move it.

His neighbor claimed two feet beyond his fence when he ordered his own survey, he discovered the fence was on their land

The Neighbor Claimed His Property Extended Beyond the Fence

In a Reddit post on r/neighborsfromhell, user u/Entire-Mongoose8909 explained that she and her husband wanted a fenced yard for their large dog and more privacy from the neighbors.

One neighbor had a chain-link fence around his property and about 11 posted signs facing the adjoining yards.

The couple waited three months for surveyors to visit. When the crew returned to mark the corners, the neighbor disputed the measurements and threatened legal action.

The surveyors checked their calculations and returned two weeks later, placing the stake along his fence line. He continued to object.

His Own Survey Found the Fence Two Feet Inside Their Property

The couple considered splitting the cost of another survey to settle the dispute. Before they could make the offer, the neighbor approached the husband and claimed he had spent $30,000 on surveys.

He said another crew would return to mark the boundaries.

The results contradicted his original claim. According to the homeowner, the fence stood two feet inside their property.

“He tells us that he is going to have his fence moved. No apology.”

The neighbor had spent more than a year planting trees near the disputed boundary and marking a stake with spray paint.

The homeowner said the fence would be moved, but did not report that the work had been completed.

His Own Survey Found the Fence Two Feet Inside Their Property

Reddit Commenters Questioned the Property Boundary and Survey Cost

Several commenters questioned the neighbor’s claim that he had spent $30,000 on surveys. Others warned that fences do not always follow legal property boundaries.

For example, Massachusetts’ MassGIS property parcel guidance explains that assessor maps should not be treated as authoritative boundary surveys. The Reddit author did not disclose her state, so the rules governing the dispute remain unknown.

One commenter raised the possibility of adverse possession, which can affect property disputes under certain state laws. The homeowner acknowledged the concern but said the neighbor had accepted that the fence was on their land.

She also explained why they no longer wanted to leave the fence in place:

“After all this though, he’s moving the fence and we are never speaking again.”

The couple still planned to build their privacy fence.

Fence disagreements have caused other neighborhood disputes. In another case reported by Homedit, new homeowners were asked to pay for a fence built before they moved in, but the neighbors refused to show them the bill. In a separate dispute, neighbors cut through a homeowner’s fence to access his swimming pool after he installed a gate to stop them from parking in his driveway.

Would you insist that the neighbor move his fence two feet, or leave it in place to avoid another dispute?


Story credit: Reddit user u/Entire-Mongoose8909, who shared the experience in r/neighborsfromhell.