Neither White Nor Gray: Orange Oak Cabinets Get Painted Behr Creamy Mushroom, but the Beige Tile Stays
Orange oak cabinets covered the walls of this kitchen, paired with speckled granite countertops, a beige stone backsplash, and large square floor tiles. Raised-panel doors, dark round knobs, and a black range hood gave the room a traditional appearance, while the wood grain remained visible across every cabinet front.

Replacing the cabinets would have meant removing much of the kitchen, but the existing doors and frames offered another option. A coat of Behr Creamy Mushroom changed the orange wood to a soft beige finish, while black cup pulls replaced the original drawer knobs.
The makeover was shared by Instagram furniture painter @dumpsterdiva1923, whose client selected Creamy Mushroom for the cabinets. The granite countertops, stone backsplash, floor tiles, and stainless steel refrigerator remained, leaving the original kitchen layout intact.
Orange Oak Cabinets Covered the Original Kitchen

The cooking wall had raised-panel oak cabinets above and below the countertop, with a black range hood positioned over the cooktop. Dark round knobs appeared on the doors and drawers, while the backsplash combined small rectangular stone tiles with a framed diagonal pattern behind the stove.

The sink sat beneath a pass-through opening toward the dining area, with matching oak cabinets extending around the corner. Speckled granite covered the worktops and raised counter ledge, while large beige floor tiles continued across the kitchen.

Tall upper cabinets surrounded the stainless steel refrigerator, with more oak doors and drawers beneath the adjacent counter. The refrigerator, backsplash, and granite were not part of the cabinet repaint.
Behr Creamy Mushroom Replaced the Orange Wood Finish

Behr Creamy Mushroom covers the original raised-panel doors, drawer fronts, and cabinet frames. The color has a beige undertone rather than the stark appearance of white paint, allowing the cabinets to sit beside the existing stone finishes.
Black cup pulls were fitted to the drawers, while round black knobs remained the hardware style on the cabinet doors. The darker fittings stand out against the new paint and match the black appliances.
The Original Granite Countertops Stayed in Place

The repainted lower cabinets retain their original configuration beneath the granite counters. Drawer banks, corner storage, and cabinet doors occupy the same positions, with the new finish extending across the frames and recessed door panels.
The granite contains cream, brown, and black flecks that connect with both the beige cabinetry and dark hardware. Its rounded front edge remains visible above the painted drawers and doors.
Beige Floor Tiles Remained Part of the Kitchen

Large square floor tiles with dark grout lines still cover the kitchen, including the corner beneath the sink. The homeowner did not replace them with wood flooring or a different tile pattern.
The Creamy Mushroom cabinets share some of the beige tones found in the floor, while the black hardware creates separation between the painted doors and surrounding surfaces.
The Cooking Wall Kept Its Stone Backsplash

The cooking wall now has painted upper and lower cabinets surrounding the original black range hood. The beige stone backsplash remains beneath the wall cabinets, including the framed tile detail behind the cooktop.
The cabinet doors retain their raised-panel profiles, with Creamy Mushroom covering the wood grain that once dominated the wall.
Black Hardware Contrasts With the Beige Cabinetry

The upper doors have small black knobs, while the drawers use curved black cup pulls. Both hardware styles contrast with the beige paint and repeat the dark finish of the range hood and dishwasher.
The stainless steel refrigerator remains beside the cabinets, with the original granite and stone surfaces connecting the appliance wall to the rest of the kitchen.
Before and After: Orange Oak Becomes Creamy Mushroom

The comparison shows the original oak cabinets surrounding the sink and granite counter, followed by the same area after the Creamy Mushroom repaint. The new finish covers the wood doors and frames without changing the counter height, cabinet arrangement, or floor tiles.
The makeover demonstrates how a cabinet color can change the appearance of a kitchen while retaining its existing stone surfaces. Rather than introducing white or gray, the homeowner selected a beige shade that works with the granite and backsplash already in place.
Would you choose Behr Creamy Mushroom for orange oak cabinets or paint them white and replace the beige tile?
Images and project details courtesy of @dumpsterdiva1923.
