Homedit is supported by our readers. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Puffy vs Avocado Mattress: Which Should You Choose?

When it comes to choosing a new mattress, you may think there are way too many possibilities out there to choose from. This is especially apparent if you are looking for a pretty broad type of mattress not very specific to certain needs. These needs can range from anything from back pain alleviating to heat dispersing for especially hot sleepers.

Once you figure out what exactly you need in a new mattress, the rest of the hunt is a bit easier. When it comes to top name brands in mattresses, such as the Avocado vs Puffy, which one is best? Which one will give you some of the best nights rest that you’ve ever had? When it comes to the Avocado mattress vs the Puffy mattress, we’ve broken down some of the basic logistics to make the decision a bit easier.

$300 off + Free king pillow
Puffy Mattress
Puffy Mattress

With so much comfort support, even someone with the most horrendous back issues could find some comfort within the Puffy line of mattresses.

View Deal
$150 off
Avocado Mattress
Avocado Mattress

The Avocado Green Mattresses are best for side or stomach sleepers. The coils that target five different ergodic zones are also good for back sleepers.

View Deal

While both the Avocado mattress and the Puffy mattress are amazing in construction, you may need one over the other considering your specific sleep needs. While the Avocado mattress is entirely organic and great for all kinds of sleepers (side, belly, back) the Puffy mattress touts to be “America’s most comfortable mattress” and is ideal for side sleeping and back sleeping. It just depends on which areas of the body you need to reduce pressure from while you sleep and other specifics that you’d need. We break down some of the construction features of each, so keep reading for a full rundown.

Puffy Mattress VS Avocado Mattress Comparison

 Puffy MattressAvocado Mattress
Sleep Trial:101 nightsOne year
Warranty:Lifetime warranty25-year warranty
Free ShippingYesYes
Firmness Level:6 out of 106 out of 10
Check priceCheck price

A Closer Look

Puffy mattresses are made from high grade materials and most customer reviews state that these mattresses make them feel as if they are sleeping on a cloud. If you are looking for a plush, contouring and cradling mattress, Puffy may just be the mattress brand for you.

There are also a few different types of Puffy mattresses, so you can choose according to plushness and mattress depth size. There is the Puffy Mattress, the Puffy Lux Mattress and the Puffy Royal mattress. Each one is a bit plusher than the last and each one is a bit pricier than the last, too.

The Avocado mattress is comprised of materials completely sourced from organic companies. The whole mattress is hand made in sunny California – one of the meccas of using sustainably sourced and organic, chemical free products. This mattress is unique in that it provides a mattress with high grade hybrid latex foam, which contours to the body but offers a bit more bounce overall.

The Avocado also comes with specified zones for the entire body, so each part of your body is getting targeted pressure relief and contouring. It’s a modern mattress with an earth conscious makeup that makes Avocado a truly remarkable brand in these times.

Why is Choosing the Right Mattress So Important?

It’s really important to make sure that you’re choosing the right mattress for your sleep style because, for example, if you need a firm mattress and sleep on a soft mattress, you’ll wake up even more sore than when you went to bed. No mattress is created equal, just as no human body is created equal, and everyone has their own needs when it comes to sleeping.

Sleeping is important to the overall health of the body, but good sleeping is important to the very wiring of the body. You have to treat your body like a suspension bridge – so many cables and wires that need to be properly aligned at all times, otherwise the bridge with contain weaknesses and those weakened cables can pop and throw the whole bridge down. May seem a bit dramatic, but if you’ve ever suffered from back pain for a bad night’s sleep, you’ll totally understand this reference.

Bottom line is you need to make sure you are getting a mattress that will keep your overall health in mind. Targeted sleep zones like the Avocado mattress provides, and plush contouring like the Puffy mattress provides are two really great features to have, but it’s up to you to determine which of these features is best suited for your sleep profile.

With that being said, here’s a detailed break down of both the Avocado mattress and the Puffy mattress.

Puffy Mattress

View in gallery

Cost

There are three different types of Puffy mattress, so there are three different basic prices. For a queen-sized mattress, for example, the Puffy mattress starts at around $1,200. The Puffy Lux mattress starts at around $1,700 and the Puffy Royal starts at around $2,200. Each mattress is a bit more expensive than the last because of the varying materials and support they offer.

$300 off + Free king pillow
Puffy Mattress
Puffy Mattress

With so much comfort support, even someone with the most horrendous back issues could find some comfort within the Puffy line of mattresses.

View Deal

Sizes

You can find all three of the Puffy mattresses: Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal in all the basic sizes staring from twin all the way up to California king. You could buy a Puffy for every member of the family, if you really wanted to.

SizeDimensions
Puffy/Puffy Lux
Weight
Puffy/Puffy Lux
Price
Twin39" x 75" x 10"/39" x 75" x 12"41/45 lbs$300 off +Free king pillow
Twin XL39" x 80" x 10"/39" x 80" x 12"45/50 lbs$300 off +Free king pillow
Full54" x 75" x 10"/54" x 75" x 12"58/63 lbs$300 off +Free king pillow
Queen60" x 80" x 10"/ 60" x 80" x 12"69/75 lbs$300 off +Free king pillow
King76" x 80" x 10"/76" x 80" x 12"87/95 lbs$300 off +Free king pillow
Cal King72" x 84" x 10"/ 72" x 84" x 12"87/95 lbs$300 off +Free king pillow

Construction

Puffy mattresses are amazing because they use a patented multi-layer design to target deep sleeping. There is a cooling cloud foam top layer, a climate comfort layer and a firm core base support layer that sets the platform for all these other fantastic layers to work correctly. The cooling cloud layers are specifically formulated to control hot sleepers and preventing anyone from waking up sweating in the middle of the night – a common issue for people who heat up as they sleep.

With such high-grade materials all working in conjunction, the Puffy mattress is said to feel like sleeping on a cloud. The mattress has that Puffy sleep system which incorporates so many layers in order for the customer to have their best sleep ever, guaranteed.

Shipping

@josephpiette⠀⠀

Puffy mattresses come with free shipping on every purchase and can be delivered directly to your door with no hassle or extra setup fees.

Where It’s Made

All Puffy mattresses are made from sustainable resources in the United States. While they don’t offer up a specific city that the company is harbored in, all their products are certified sustainable and made in the U.S.A.

Special Features

Puffy mattresses offer up three different mattress types, the Puffy mattress, Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal that each offer something a little extra than the last. The more luxurious the mattress, the more expensive it will be, but the prices are comparable to the product quality and high grad materials used. The thickest mattress is the Puffy Royal mattress, which incorporates more of those cooling layers and contouring foam layers.

Puffy is also great because aside from these mattresses, they also offer bases, stands, pillows and bedding options, all made with that same great integrity that promotes a deep sleep. You can easily make Puffy your one stop shops when it comes to getting a new mattress and all the fixings to go along with it.

Firmness Level

Puffy mattresses come in at a six on a scale of one to ten. This means that they are super plush and contouring, but also sturdy and has your back – literally.

Maintenance

Caring for your Puffy mattress is a breeze since all of these mattresses are made of super high-quality materials. If you get something on the mattress, a spot clean of warm water and soap would go a long way. Due to the high-density foam, if you catch a spill right away, you could prevent it from seeping into the deeper layers of the mattress. Also, mattress protectors are super important and really essential when it comes to maintaining the longevity of your mattress. Keep that in mind while you’re purchasing all the extra cool stuff to go with your new mattress.

Sleep Trial

Puffy mattresses come with a 101-night sleep trial, so that gives you ample time to determine if these mattresses are the right fit for you and your family. After 101 nights, you should be able to determine if you want to maintain your sleeping relationship with Puffy, or if it’s just not the right set up for you and your sleep needs. At least there is a lot of time to think about it, if you’re not already fast asleep enjoying the comforts of Puffy, that is.

$300 off + Free king pillow
Puffy Mattress
Puffy Mattress

With so much comfort support, even someone with the most horrendous back issues could find some comfort within the Puffy line of mattresses.

View Deal

Warranty

One of the best things about Puffy is the fact that they offer a lifetime warranty on all of their mattresses. If anything goes wrong with your Puffy mattress or if anything is faulty from the manufacture, don’t even sweat it. Just contact customer service at any time and send your mattress back. Super easy. They’ll either refund your money or send you a new mattress that isn’t faulty. It’s a great back up deal from the company which also demonstrates how great they believe their brand to be.

Related: The Puffy Mattress Review: Is It Right for You?

Avocado Mattress

View in gallery
@sunwoven

Cost

Avocado mattresses may be a bit pricier for someone who is looking for a standard mattress. That’s because Avocado mattresses are organic and come with really amazingly high-grade materials. These mattresses are hand made and careful detail is poured into each one. A price example would be the queen-sized mattress, which starts at around $1,500. The following prices are comparable in king, twin, etc.

$150 off
Avocado Mattress
Avocado Mattress

The Avocado Green Mattresses are best for side or stomach sleepers. The coils that target five different ergodic zones are also good for back sleepers.

View Deal

Sizes

Avocado mattresses come in all the standard sizes, all the way from twin, to California king. You can easily find all the mattress sizes you need when it comes to shopping the Avocado brand. They’re also really good on helping out with size questions, so take advantage of that customer service support.

SizeDimensionsWeightPrice
Twin75" x 38" x 11"59 lbsCheck price
Twin XL80" x 38" x 11" 63 lbCheck price
Full75" x 54" x 11"82 lbsCheck price
Queen80" x 60" x 11"97 lbsCheck price
King80" x 76" x 11"123 lbsCheck price
California King84" x 72" x 11"122 lbsCheck price

Construction

Avocado mattresses are all organic certified and are made up with a hybrid latex with offers all the support that memory foam offers but without that hot, sinking feeling. Memory foam is notorious for being too hot in the night and many people who sleep on memory foam wake up sweating. With Avocado, they’ve offered the same kind of support you can find in a memory foam mattress, but with a hybrid latex so there is no heating up.

The springy latex can help anyone who suffers from neck or back issues. It has excellent edge support and added bonus for being completely organic which is great for anyone who is hypoallergenic or sensitive or has some respiratory issues.

Shipping

Avocado mattresses come with free shipping anywhere in the United States. Setup is a breeze and since these mattresses are organic, there is very little to no off gassing, which is a huge bonus.

Where It’s Made

Avocado mattresses are all made in California, the hub of the brand. These mattresses are also handmade, so there is careful attention to detail, and these are constructed with no harsh plastics or chemicals. Customer service is top priority with this company, and that’s evident in the careful construction you can see in each and every mattress. If mattresses were artisan, Avocado would definitely be up there.

Special Features

Avocado is a great mattress alone, but there is an added bonus option to upgrade each mattress to the pillow top mattress. This is just more great stuff to love when it comes to Avocado. This means an extra plush layer on top of an already amazingly supportive mattress. This added feature is ideal for anyone who really loves the feeling of pillow softness but also needs that strong base support to keep the body in line.

Avocado mattress also come with a great innerspring system that is comprised of almost 1,500 innerspring coils. This is where that amazing support zone comes in. The springs are all made of recycled materials, so still adhering to that earth conscious ideal while providing amazing support and quite possibly the best sleep of your life.

Firmness Level

Avocado mattresses are soft enough, but not too soft that it won’t offer any support. On a scale of one to ten, with ten being the most firm, Avocado mattresses fall around a six or seven. This mattress maintains its shape and can withstand many years of use, so you won’t have to worry about the mattress going flat or soft.

Maintenance

Avocado mattresses are made of super great materials, so there is really no maintenance needed when it comes to using the mattress. Some of the basic care includes washing the mattress cover regularly to prevent any smells or buildup. Since you sleep on a mattress every night, a mattress protector is suggested to help trap any sweat and other liquids. If the mattress does get something on it, a spot clean should do the trick.

Sleep Trial

You can sleep on the Avocado mattress for a full year before you really decide if it’s for you or not. You’ll probably be able to tell after the first night of sleeping on it if it’s for you or not but having a whole year to think about it is super generous. Most mattress companies offer a few months, but with Avocado, they are so sure you’ll love it that they give you a year to make sure.

$150 off
Avocado Mattress
Avocado Mattress

The Avocado Green Mattresses are best for side or stomach sleepers. The coils that target five different ergodic zones are also good for back sleepers.

View Deal

Warranty

Avocado mattresses offer up a 25-year warranty to make sure the mattress isn’t faulty. If, within those 25 years, anything is wrong with it from the manufacturing of it, you can replace or send back the mattress with no questions asked. This is also a really generous time frame that most mattress companies don’t offer up.

Related: Our 2020 Avocado Green Mattress Review: Experience the Best

The Wrap Up

So, now that you have a better idea about what these two amazing mattresses have to offer, which one do you think you’d want to try? Does that all organic Avocado mattress inspire you, or are you looking at all those great cooling and support layers from Puffy? You really can’t go wrong with either of these high-grade mattresses, but, unfortunately, you can probably only choose one of the two to purchase.

$300 off + Free king pillow
Puffy Mattress
Puffy Mattress

With so much comfort support, even someone with the most horrendous back issues could find some comfort within the Puffy line of mattresses.

View Deal
$150 off
Avocado Mattress
Avocado Mattress

The Avocado Green Mattresses are best for side or stomach sleepers. The coils that target five different ergodic zones are also good for back sleepers.

View Deal

At least each of these mattresses come with pretty awesome sleep trial periods and excellent warranty back ups to make your decision a bit easier. If you’re so bold, you could technically try out both mattresses and see for yourself which one fits your sleep style better. Hey, why not if you have no time to waste? While having to choose between these two may seem a bit daunting, just remember to go over all the construction points and determine which one will best fit your sleep needs.

Your best ever sleep could just be a click purchase away when it comes to choosing between the Puffy and the Avocado. Remember, if you have any questions or concerns, each mattress company has stellar customer support so you can totally take advantage of that. You should also read all reviews about them to help you along your best sleep ever path, as there are real customers who may have some of the same questions that you do. Best of luck!